Atticus Bookstore/Cafe – Bites and Books

For the last 30 years, settling in at an Atticus Bookstore/Cafe table or at the counter with a great read, a script or a thesis has been de rigeur for any number of academic Elm City denizens, whether they’re the next big thing (like you) or the already arrived like August Wilson, Athol Fugard or Parker Posey.

In the old days when the Atticus manager had no food knowledge it would be easy to concentrate on the words in front of you and not notice the somewhat forgettable food. But today you’ll be hard put to get past the first paragraph before focusing far more attention on your plate.

General manager and chef Ben Gaffney has only been on the scene for the last two years and boy what a difference he has made, attested to by his Iron Chef Elm City 2012 win in April.

Gaffney got his start in Glastonbury in high school working for his dad, the chef at the Blacksmith Tavern. After attending UConn and the Culinary Institute of America, Gaffney headed south to New Orleans to be Emeril Lagasse’s pastry chef, eventually opening Lagasse’s Miami restaurant in 2003. Gaffney married a diplomat and with their two children traveled to the Phillipines, Southeast Asia and Africa. Returning to Connecticut for a family visit, Gaffney connected to the job at Atticus.

Under Gaffney’s skilled hand the menu has grown so much that people now come for the specials, although long-time favorites like roast chicken with crispy macaroni and cheese, and chicken pot pie are still hot items, even if the roasted salmon over quinoa tabouli has surpassed the pot pie in popularity. Although the food seems to be contemporary American flecked with a Creole bent, you can detect influences from Gaffney’s years abroad in an item like the tabouli, a recipe Gaffney learned while he was in Africa.

Those who still want to become the next big thing  – or maybe already are – will find a home at Atticus unbothered. Everybody else is too busy paying attention to their plates to notice you.

Mara Lavitt


Restaurant Website:

• The Detes: 1082 Chapel St. New Haven • 203-776-4040 • Open seven days, generally 7am to 9pm. Sunday brunch will launched in August.

• Price Range: Salads, Sandwiches, Entrees $9-12 • Breakfast $5-7 • Scones $2.75

• Style of Food: Contemporary American with international inputs

• Most Popular Dishes: Roast chicken with crisp macaroni and cheese, roasted salmon over quinoa tabouli

• Cafe food focus: Scones, yum! Oh right, and the muffins too, yum!

• Cool celebrity factor: Famous people eat here because they don’t get bothered

 What’s surprising about your restaurant? Chabaso bread was started to provide bread to the cafe. It is now the $36 million giant and the cafe is the little brother.


5 thoughts on “Atticus Bookstore/Cafe – Bites and Books

  1. hello…have been trying to follow your blog for the past few weeks now and it seems more of an ‘advertisement’ for these places. is this meant to be a personal blog providing restaurant recommendations or a forum for the owners to publicize their venue?

    • Hi BigNHeater,

      Thank you for your interest in NewHavenEats.

      These posts are specifically not reviews. I’ll leave that up to others. My aim is not to critique but to introduce readers to restaurants they may not know about. Since I’m hard pressed not to find delicious menu items at just about any New Haven restaurant, I guess that makes me something of a booster — at least in attitude about the New Haven restaurant scene. My posts are a kind of snapshot of what the restaurant has to offer visitors. I’m a staff photographer and multi-media journalist at the New Haven Register and the photography of each restaurant is a lot of fun for me. Starting out I’m picking restaurants I haven’t eaten at and often are new on the scene. Lastly, to some extent the blog is built on the model of the restaurant pieces that used to run in our Weekend Guide section, which were photo rich.

      Hope this helps.

  2. Wow, Atticus Bookstore / Cafe has grown! One place to enjoy my two favorite pastimes: reading and eating! Thanks!

  3. I love Atticus and have been eating there for some time. I just had to bring my friend for lunch last week because she loves black bean soup and of course Atticus makes wonderful black bean soup, or so I have always thought. The first thing we noticed was it was reddish in color instead of the usual black….and it tasted like chili, not the black bean soup I love. If they want to serve chili than call it chili. If they are serving black bean soup than go back to the old, delicious recipe I have love to order….please!! Perhaps the chef accidentally was heavy-handed with chili powder. I questioned them and they said it was the same recipe they have been using forever. I beg to differ. Thanks for letting me sound off.

  4. In fact, what has not changed in sll these years is that this is a secondrate restaurant with okayish uneven food and horrible service — AND it’s a bad bookstore with unhelpful staff and limited stock that ignores area writers bizarrely. Because it’s really a restaurant? Or is it a bad restaurant with dreadul service because it’s really a bookstore? Either way, lose/lose.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s